Dying from the Job: The Mortality Risk for Police Officers
John M. Violanti, PhD
There are an estimated 623,000 sworn police officers employed in the United
States, yet few studies of long term health risks have been conducted. It has
been argued that police officers are at increased risk for mortality as a result
of their occupation. The average age of death for police officer in our 40-year
study was 66 years of age.
Our findings provide some insight on associations between police work and long
term disease outcome. The police profession is portrayed as a job replete with
psychological stress, danger, rotating shifts, family disruption, and exposure
to noxious materials. Studies have suggested that the high psychological stress
of police work may be one factor which plays a role in the etiology of disease.
Some of our findings may hold true within the context of the stress-disease
hypothesis. For example, younger officers under conditions of high stress and
other risk factors may be at higher risk for arteriosclerotic heart disease.
Psychological stress may also be a catalyst for malignancy at selected sites.
Stress is believed to be mediated immunologically and may lead to the onset
of cancer. Our findings indicated a ,significantly elevated mortality risk for
all malignant neoplasms in police officers. Specifically, we found a significantly
increased risk of all digestive and hematopoietic cancers among officers employed
10-19 years. These findings are consistent with other studies of police mortality
and with the hypotheses of a stress-cancer relationship. Interestingly, our
previous research found that police officers between 10-19 years of service
reported the highest stress scores.
Stress in police work may also lead to maladaptive behaviors which, it turn,
may precipitate disease. Alcohol and tobacco use are examples. Twenty-five percent
of police officers have been found to be dependent on alcohol, and a significantly
strong positive relationship was found between stress and alcohol use among
police. Alcohol is an important problem in police work, and may lead to other
work problems such as high absenteeism, intoxication on duty, complaints by
supervisors and citizens of misconduct on duty, traffic accidents, and an overall
decrease in work performance. Alcohol use among police may be underestimated.
Many officers, fearing departmental discipline, are unwilling to officially
report their dependence. Other departments may "hide" problem drinkers
in positions where they will not adversely affect police operations. In addition,
approximately 40% of police officers smoke cigarettes. Our present findings
indicated that officers have a significantly high mortality risk for esophageal
cancer, which has been related to alcohol use and smoking. Also evident in our
cohort was the significantly elevated risk of cirrhosis of the liver among officers,
a disease which has been related to alcohol use. With the exception of 1-9 years
of police service, cirrhosis of the liver was elevated across all years of service
categories and had a 3.3-fold mortality risk for officers with over 30 years
service.
Suicide is a disturbing maladaptive behavior which may be related to stress.
The significantly high suicide risk among police officers in our study denotes
the possibility that chronic job stress may lead to emotional numbing in officers
and make death easier to accept as a coping solution. Other epidemiological
studies which include police also point to a higher risk of suicide for officers.
Several population studies have reported police suicide rates to be higher than
other occupations. Another reason for the high suicide rate may be the availability
and knowledge of firearms. Approximately 95% of all police suicide involve the
use of a firearm. The police have a higher rate of firearm suicide than other
groups who work with firearms. The military is one example. Although the most
common method of suicide in the military is by firearm, approximately 59% of
military personnel suicides compared to 95% of police officer suicides used
a firearm. The police also have a higher rate of suicide by firearms than persons
who possess guns in their home, where approximately 58% of all suicides were
committed with a firearm. Alcohol use has also been found to be a factor in
suicide, and police use of alcohol may be precipitated by stress. A Chicago
police department study documented alcohol abuse in 60% of police officer suicides.
Psychological stress and its consequences may interact with other factors in
police work. Shift work is one example. Since the early 1900’s, Buffalo
police officers have engaged in a practice called "doubling back",
in which officers work 16 hour shifts within a 24 hour period. Many officers
then engage in extra jobs during their off-duty time. Such a rapid disruption
of the Circadian cycle may add to the risk of arteriosclerotic heart disease
risk in younger officers. In addition, there is significant inter-individual
variation in the ability to adapt and deterioration with increasing age. Previous
work has shown a relationship between shift work and heart disease.
Shift work may also affect officer’s dietary and exercise habits. The
general nutrition of police officers in poor, lacking many of the nutrients
found in fruits and vegetables. Officers have a tendency to consume high-fat
"fast food" meals, and generally eat them unscheduled, sometimes between
high stress police calls. During shifts, officers may not eat at all or eat
at takeout restaurants. The lack of meaningful exercise is evident among police
officers , and they have been found to have a high prevalence of arteriosclerotic
heart disease risk due to poor physical fitness. In one study, 76% of officers
had elevated cholesterol, 26% had elevated triglycerides, and 60% had elevated
body fat. Other studies have shown that only police officers who exercised regularly
had a lower 10-year risk of heart disease and were absent less from work. The
present findings of significantly elevated colon cancer risk may also be the
result of a complex interaction of stress, shift work, lack of exercise and
poor dietary habits.
Our present findings of increased risk of lymphatic and hematopoietic cancers
, especially Hodgkin’s disease and leukemia, suggest additional risk factors
in police work. Psychological stress has been suggested as a risk factor in
hematopoietic cancer , as well as exposure to chemical substances in the workplace.
A study of Hodgkin’s disease in the U.S. Navy consisting of 2.3 million
person-years reported that probable exposure to solvents and ionizing radiation
may increase risk. Leukemia mortality risk has also been associated with occupational
exposures to diesel fuels, benzene, and lead. Police officers are exposed on
a daily basis to carbon monoxide from motor vehicles and chemicals on the highway
and gun cleaning solvents which may contribute to arteriosclerotic heart and
renal diseases. Exposure to lead has been implicated in cerebrovascular and
other diseases, and high levels of lead in the blood have been found in police
officers exposed to firearms, ammunition, and fingerprint powder. Cancer of
the kidney also showed a significantly high risk in our present study. A study
of urban policemen in Rome found a high risk of kidney cancer among motorcycle
officers, and additional studies have found associations between occupational
chemical exposure and kidney cancer.
Increased risk of hematopoietic and brain cancers found in the present study
may be in part be a result of electromagnetic field exposure in police work.
It is probable, however, that EMF exposure and several environmental carcinogens
working together may lead to promotion of these cancers. Most police agencies
engage in the widespread use of radio transmissions and radar. Police speed
enforcement radar devices generate a continuous wave (CW) reference frequency
in either X-band (10.525 Ghz) or in K-band (24.150 Ghz) and transmit nonionizing
electromagnetic frequency. Davis and Mostifi found a significant increased risk
for testicular cancer among police officers who reported use of hand-held radar
units inside of the police vehicle. Violanti (unpublished study) found a 68%
increased probability of cancer with increased exposure time to police radar
. Officers were, on average, exposed to radar 74% of the time that they were
enforcing speeding laws. Hand-held radar units (used inside the police vehicle)
had significant associations with self-reported testicle, breast, and prostrate
cancer.
Although it is not possible to change the dangers inherent in police work,
it is possible to change aspects which affect the long term health of officers.
The present findings suggest that police officers are at significantly elevated
risks for a number of diseases and appropriate interventions should be instituted.
Elevated mortality risk of colon cancer and other digestive cancers , for example,
indicates a need for earlier detection with stool tests or frequent medical
examinations. Such medical examinations are lacking as part of work benefits
in most police agencies. Elevated risk for cirrhosis, arteriosclerotic heart
disease, and all malignant neoplasms combined are also diseases of concern.
Prevention should emphasize management programs which include health education,
physical exercise , smoking abatement, and dangers of alcohol use. The elevated
risk of suicide among police officers in present study indicates the effect
of a high stress work environment and perhaps the officer’s inability
to adequately cope with stress. In addition to stress management and suicide
awareness education, police officers should have confidential psychological
services available to help them deal with such difficulties. Only one of five
police agencies presently have such programs. Shift work is another possible
factor related to long term health problems. Departments should consider arranging
work shifts to optimally benefit officers in terms of proper sleep. Shifts,
for example, should not be changed for at least 4-6 weeks at a time, as rapid
shift changes exacerbate strain on the body. Lastly, there is need for police
departments to consider alternatives to police organizational structure which
can produce much of the stress experienced by police officers. Officers report
that approximately 90% of stress in their work is a result of a highly structured,
unresponsive, uncaring administration. Changes should include allowing officers
the opportunity to participate in decisions affecting their work, and a greater
organizational awareness of problems at the street level.
No simple answers exist for prevention of disease in police work. The present
study may help to understand correlates of the long term health effects of this
occupation and provide a basis for future work.